The financial vulnerability estimate has decreased compared to last year, primarily as a result of an apparent decrease in expenditure.
Emerging trends and prevalent threats
Claiming for additional funding to provide services which are not delivered as agreed is highly likely within this area. Services like Additional Roles Reimbursement Scheme (ARRS) and Enhanced Access Services (EAS) are the most commonly abused schemes. False claiming also relates to recording and maintaining inaccurate Quality of Framework (QoF) and Global Sum information; primarily around “patient lists”.
£114.41m
vulnerable from an expenditure of £11.44bn
Reporting trends around fraudulent claims for additional funding and associated incentive scheme
GPs and practice staff members abusing their position to self-prescribe prescription medication for their own use is a realistic possibility. The assumed position of trust within this process and access to controlled medications likely enables this activity. This may also present a patient safety concern if a GP is misusing controlled medications as it may impair their ability to enact this role safely.
Case study
A GP practice manager, Kellie Preece, fraudulently obtained funds from their practice by transferring money from the surgery into their personal bank account. In total, over £144,000 was stolen from the practice and Kellie Preece pled guilty receiving a suspended prison sentence, as well as hours of rehabilitation and an electronic tag. The NHSCFA will also utilise powers under the Proceeds of Crime Act (POCA).
PESTLE analysis
Political: Ongoing discussions between government and the British Medical Association (BMA) over GP contract changes could create policy instability and potentially increase the opportunity for misinterpretation or exploitation of contracts.
Economic: The GP contract funding uplift increases overall contract value and transaction volumes, which may add billing complexity and create opportunities for fraudulent claims.
Social: High demand, limited growth in the GP workforce, and new technological developments such as virtual appointments may create opportunities for recording compliance without actual delivery.
Technological: Greater emphasis on digitalisation as part of the 10 Year Health Plan; for example, virtual appointments being launched, including more online appointments with GPs to create a ‘virtual hospital’. This could introduce new fraud vulnerabilities and cyber security risks around online patient data.
Environmental: Shift to community-based care to free up space in hospitals, as well as the introduction of further digitalisation and electronic recording of information may reduce the environmental impact.
Legal: Due to the complexity of the GP contractual agreements, ‘grey areas’ of unintentional compliance and opportunities to commit fraud may present themselves.
Organisational: Many GPs operate as small businesses which may present the threat of limited separation of duties; creating opportunity for fraud, as well as informal financial processes and a lack of independent audit and assurance.
Media Factors: Public interest in the NHS and the pressures it faces are regularly scrutinised. This may have a positive effect through increased reporting and deterrence but could also increase defensive behaviours, such as selective or fraudulent performance reporting.
Reporting
During this reporting period, the NHSCFA received 222 reports compared to last year’s total of 235.
| Thematic area | 2020-21 | 2021-22 | 2022-23 | 2023-24 | 2024-25 | 2025-26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GP contractor | 149 | 160 | 171 | 186 | 235 | 222 |