Skip to main content

How do we calculate fraud vulnerability?

Our approach to assessing how financially vulnerable the NHS is to fraud.

The Fraud Act of 2006 states a person commits an offence if they intend ‘to cause loss to another or to expose another to a risk of loss’. Therefore, there does not need to be an actual financial loss for fraud to have occurred, exposing the NHS to the risk of loss is still considered to be fraud. We need to examine direct losses, as well as where the NHS may be at risk of loss. By capturing the estimated financial vulnerabilities in thematic areas, the NHSCFA and stakeholders can develop robust prevention strategies to prevent actual financial losses from fraud.

Various methods are used to calculate how financially vulnerable each thematic area is to fraud, bribery, and corruption and, in some instances, methods are combined. The loss method applied to a thematic area is dependent on stakeholder engagement, available data, landscape, process, and policy. Methods include:

Bar chart icon showing financial vulnerability statistics and reporting data.
  1. Loss measurement exercises: These take the form of an in-depth analysis and measurement of a particular area to provide a statistically robust percentage of how much funding/reimbursement is vulnerable to fraud. This method provides the NHSCFA with the highest confidence.

Illustration showing magnafying glass.
  1. Comparative loss assessments: Where the NHSCFA has not directly measured the financial vulnerability, we are reliant on vulnerability percentages from others. These would not be 100% comparable, however they are the most relevant in the absence of a loss measurement exercise available.

Illustration showing a hand shake
  1. Collaboration with policy holders: Where a percentage of fraudulent activity is established through the study of recent data, legislation, and changes to landscape.

Illustration showing Bar chart icon that is underlied at the bottom of the chart
  1. Baseline financial vulnerability: A legacy percentage of fraudulent activity which is applied due to no availability of a recent loss assessment, comparative loss assessment or guidance from policy holders. Improvements could be made through stakeholder collaboration.

Financial vulnerability 2018 to 2026
Year 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Financial vulnerability (£bn) 1.29 1.27 1.21 1.14 1.198 1.264 1.316 1.346 1.301

The probability yardstick

To ensure a consistent approach to assessing the probability and/or uncertainty of reports and intelligence detailed within the SIA, the NHSCFA uses the ‘probability yardstick’. When using the measure of probability, the NHSCFA has considered the dependability and frequency of reporting around a prevalent or emerging modus operandi (MO).

Table showing the probability yardstick
Likelihood of occurrence Remote chance Highly unlikely Unlikely Realistic possibility Likely / probable Highly likely Almost certain
Percentage range 0% - 5% 10% - 20% 25% - 35% 40% - 50% 55% - 75% 80% - 90% 95% - 100%

Help us improve cfa.nhs.uk

Tell us what's happened so we can fix the problem. Please do not provide any personal, identifiable or sensitive information.

Close

Thanks for the feedback!

Close