The financial vulnerability estimate has slightly increased. This is alongside the implementation of Post Payment Verification (PPV), the introduction of a centralised electronic claims submission by NHSBSA, and recent changes to the General Ophthalmic Services (GOS) regulations.
Emerging trends and prevalent threats
A practice could realistically recall a patient regularly without clinical need to inflate claim volumes and benefit financially, with patient safety potentially being impacted through unnecessary testing.
£91.22m
vulnerable from an expenditure of £555.98m
Opticians carrying out NHS Community Urgent Eyecare Service (CUES) assessments during domiciliary visits, even when clinically unnecessary and bypassing protocols is a realistic possibility.
Claiming for services (GOS1/3/4/6) which were not provided is highly likely, this includes GOS claims for ineligible or non-qualifying patients, as well as repeated eye tests within short intervals. False GOS claims involving vulnerable care home residents is a realistic possibility, as well as repeated eye tests and dispensing of glasses within short time periods without informing the next of kin.
False GOS claim reporting trends
The threat of false, manipulated and duplicate GOS claims is highly likely. However, it is possible for patients to identify and report false claims made using their identity.
Additionally, excessive testing and re-dispensing for minors specifically highlights frequent testing and repeat spectacles for under 16s to maximise payments.
Furthermore, forgery and misuse of signatures to enable claims is a realistic possibility.
It is likely that vouchers will be issued to ineligible patients, including opticians issuing vouchers to those who are not eligible or entitled to free NHS optical services.
Within secondary care, it is almost certain that an optical care provider in the independent sector could manipulate their coding activity to increase payments.
PESTLE analysis
Political: DHSC launched a consultation in September 2025 on extending the range of medicines optometrists and contact lens opticians can supply / administer, so minor eye conditions can be treated in community settings without GP / hospital referrals. In response the College of Optometrists welcomed “the government proposed plans to extend [the] range of medicines that optometrists can supply”.
Economic: A consultation was launched for amendments to the 2025 - 2026 NHS Payment Scheme in July 2025, encompassing proposals for price alterations to certain ophthalmology services. Additionally, GOS sight test 2025 - 2026 fees have been updated. However other GOS payments, grants and patient optical voucher values remain frozen. This may increase financial pressure on optical practices, increasing the potential for fraudulent activity.
Social: More optical care is shifting from hospitals into neighbourhood settings, reducing unnecessary referrals and consequently waiting lists, but requiring ICBs to monitor for tariff manipulation and quality flaws.
Technological: The NHS 10-Year Health Plan includes digital transformation to improve care, reduce costs and provide quicker access. This could potentially impact on ophthalmology, for example with AI diagnostic processing and increased capacity for those requiring in-person care.
Environmental: The College of Optometrists has shared initiatives on reducing single-use plastics, improving recycling and making patient information digitally available.
Legal: The Strategic Commissioning Framework (SCF) provides its ambitions for commissioning with a key role played by ICBs in focusing on local population needs and that eye health is improved through optometry services playing an important part in care pathways.
Organisational: The NHSCFA has recently closed an intelligence gap through analysis of the optical landscape, patient charge evasion and contractor fraud.
Media Factors: Online reporting of investigations into private cataract clinics inflating costs or carrying out unnecessary operations may increase public concern about outsourced eye care.
Reporting
During this reporting period, the NHSCFA received 45 reports compared to last year’s total of 42.
| Thematic area | 2020-21 | 2021-22 | 2022-23 | 2023-24 | 2024-25 | 2025-26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Optical contractor | 11 | 24 | 22 | 29 | 42 | 45 |