The financial vulnerability estimate has increased by £50.2m. This is explained by a change in methodology and an increase in procurement spending.
Emerging trends and prevalent threats
There is a realistic possibility that criminals are impersonating NHS staff members for payment diversion fraud and salary sacrifice fraud. For example, there have been multiple occasions of staff having a salary deduction without their knowledge for electrical goods that are not received.
£442.7m
vulnerable from an expenditure of £36.5bn
Top MOs in reporting
It is a realistic possibility that fraudsters are sending emails to trusts purporting to be a government department and prompting a log-on to a system or asking for payment. Fraudsters are also altering or selling Certificates of Sponsorship (CoS), offering to write applications and falsely advertising NHS jobs.
It is almost certain that the NHS receives fraudulent invoices relating to payment for services and goods not required or ordered. Fraudulent invoicing extends to legitimate suppliers claiming to have provided the contracted service yet providing less. Fraudulent attempts also extend to unsolicited direct debits.
It is almost certain that fraudsters use the legitimate details of NHS staff and suppliers, for example CEOs, and make contact via email addresses with suspicious domain names. Fraudulent emails, often purporting to be a GP practice partner, may also include foreign email domains. Additionally, some fraudulent requests have stated payment details of bank account sort codes from challenger platforms to traditional high street banks.
It is likely that conflicts of interest and due diligence concerns exist within the management and evaluation phase of the commissioning cycle. This includes those in positions of influence not declaring a relationship with a supplier ahead of awarding them the contract. Conflicts of interest can similarly exist when NHS practitioners are also directors of the supplier awarded the contract. Due diligence concerns the level of service provided by the supplier, for example, a private contractor delivering below the contract level of service. Due diligence issues can also occur when suppliers misappropriate NHS assets once a contract ceases.
It is a realistic possibility that supplier collusion exists, for example, those in positions of influence meeting with suppliers to secure contracts or receive information ahead of a future tender process; for which those in positions of influence receive payment, whether gifts or work carried out on a home. Post-contract, collusion includes those in positions of influence advising a supplier to increase or fabricate invoices, in exchange for bribes. It is also possible that bid rigging to price fix and influence who wins the contract is taking place.
Case study
Fraud against Guys and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust (GSTT) occurred between 2016 - 2019. Where Edias Mazambani (GSTT Credit Controller) faked patient and client refund requests and used a network of money mules to launder these proceeds before the majority ended up with E Mazambani and two other main recipients, George and Rose Magaya.
The investigation identified over £218,000 in fraudulent refunds paid out, with an additional £84,000 in fraudulent claims prevented, bringing the total fraud value to more than £302,000. Edias Mazambani and George Magaya received prison sentences, Rose Magaya received a suspended prison sentence, whilst Sinqobile Pasipanodya and Michelle Tengende (two of the money mules) also received suspended sentences but were also ordered to pay a financial penalty for money laundering.
PESTLE analysis
Political: The Procurement Act 2023 simplifies procurement regulations.
Economic: ICB cost-reduction and restructuring are likely to centralise procurement with larger footprints to cover. Similarly, procurement targets to reduce spend per product could result in the selection of lower priced items regardless of efficacy.
Social: New reforms in the Procurement Act do not extend to commissioning of services where there is a continuous requirement to provide the service, such as agency nurses. The flexibility for trusts to take the ‘break glass’ option and procure off framework continues.
Technological: The shift towards a digital strategy within health systems, AI tools, and remote delivery as part of the 10-Year Health Plan for England, increases potential exposure to procurement fraud, contractor misrepresentation and cyber-enabled fraud.
Environmental: The new Procurement Act increases emphasis on social value, requiring procurement decisions to account for environmental and community benefits.
Legal: Greater reliance on NHSE approved procurement frameworks and central oversight may improve compliance and reduce fraud vulnerability.
Organisational: Concerns around due diligence and contract management remain, but new legislative changes of greater scrutiny and transparency of suppliers should allow for improvements to be made.
Media Factors: Procurement failures or perceptions of NHS exploitation can attract significant public and media scrutiny.
Reporting
During this reporting period, the NHSCFA received 665 reports compared to last year’s total of 560.
| Thematic area | 2020-21 | 2021-22 | 2022-23 | 2023-24 | 2024-25 | 2025-26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Procurement and commissioning | 528 | 1,210 | 639 | 733 | 560 | 665 |